9/22/2017

Proposal # 6 The Waiver Draft 2 Value Added Provision


Proposal #6

For Waiver Draft Two ONLY,  ALL players selected would have RFA status (whether they did before or not) except for dropped promoted prospects who retain their previous status.

The benefits of this proposal would certainly be increasing player valuations for undrafted players; a pick-up of 2nd half performers would now be RFA; and 8 "new" RFA players per team


Thank you,


Bob

11 comments:

Red Five said...

Since I hope to see WD2 gone, vote No.

Bladerunner said...

haha Dan -- but what if WD2 still exists? this would make it more valuable for some

I vote NO though ... although for different reasons than Dan :-)

wildwolf said...

I think it is interesting idea. definitely worth considering to make wd2 more worth while as I hope it stays around

Moriarty said...

The Shadow votes YES

Uncertain what rob voted as he left a comment

Scourge said...

Yes

Templar said...

Templar votes NO.

We already have too many players locked up, and I do not wish to carry on with WD2.

Moriarty said...

If WD2 is not gone, does your vote change, mike g. or dan?

Red Five said...

No - I don't see the value of WD2, and adding this wrinkle to try and make it more meaningful is artificial and does not really reflect how the NHL (and hence the pool) work.

I would suggest that the fact we see a need to add this is further evidence that WD2 has limited utility and should be discarded.

Just my $0.02 :-)

Templar said...

No.
Like Dan, I see it as a futile way to make WD2 meaningful.
Several GMs do not bother to commit time to be online, this has been going on for several years.

Bladerunner said...

lol - I am voting No same as Dan and Mike but for exact opposite reasons . kind of funny.

Bladerunner said...

Brian for Bob:

RESULTS: 6 Yes, 3 No, 2 Abstain, 1 Quit = 6/12 .. Proposal does not pass

thank you for participating

Bob